Manchester United’s Most Expensive Signings Under Erik ten Hag: Successes and Failures

Erik ten Hag's tenure at Manchester United has been marked by significant financial investment in new players, with over £600 million spent on 21 signings during his time in charge. While some players have flourished, others have struggled to justify their hefty price tags. Here, we take a closer look at the most expensive signings, assess their impact, and discuss who might stay or leave as the club looks to reshape its squad.

1. Antony - £85 Million from Ajax

Antony is the most expensive signing under Ten Hag, having arrived from Ajax for a whopping £85 million. Initially, the Brazilian winger was seen as a transformative figure capable of injecting creativity and flair into United's attack. However, his performances have been inconsistent, with only flashes of brilliance amid prolonged periods of underachievement. Critics have pointed to his lack of goals and assists, making him a prime candidate for scrutiny as United reassesses its squad. Given the heavy investment, the pressure is on Antony to step up in the coming seasons, or he risks being labeled a disappointment.

2. Lisandro Martínez - £57 Million from Ajax

Lisandro Martínez has arguably been the standout signing under Ten Hag, showcasing his defensive prowess and versatility. The Argentine center-back, a key player in Argentina's World Cup and Copa America victories, has been instrumental in solidifying United's backline. His performances in high-pressure matches, such as the FA Cup final victory over Manchester City, highlight his importance to the team. Despite his height, standing at just 5ft 9in, Martínez has dispelled early concerns regarding his suitability for the Premier League. However, his injury record is a significant drawback; limited to just 38 league appearances across two seasons due to calf, knee, and foot injuries, his availability remains a concern. Martínez is expected to stay at the club, as his contributions have far outweighed those of many other signings.

3. Casemiro - £70 Million from Real Madrid

Casemiro was brought in to provide much-needed experience and defensive stability in midfield. His first season was impressive, displaying strong tackling, leadership, and an ability to control games. However, his form dipped during the following season, and questions arose about his long-term fitness and suitability for the pace of the Premier League. If he can recapture his earlier form, Casemiro will remain a vital asset, but if his decline continues, the club may consider offloading him in the near future.

4. Mason Mount - £60 Million from Chelsea

Mason Mount arrived at United with high expectations after a successful spell at Chelsea, but his time at Old Trafford has been marred by injuries and poor form. With only one Premier League goal in 17 appearances, Mount has struggled to make an impact. Many see him as a potential failure of the Ten Hag era unless he can significantly improve in the upcoming season. His future at the club hangs in the balance, and if he doesn't find his form soon, a departure may be on the cards.

5. Rasmus Højlund - £72 Million from Atalanta

Rasmus Højlund was brought in as a long-term prospect for the striker position. The young Danish forward has shown glimpses of his potential but has struggled for consistency in his first season. As one of the club's most expensive investments, there is a sense of patience surrounding Højlund as he adapts to the Premier League. His performances will be closely monitored, and while he is expected to stay for now, United will need to see more if he is to solidify his place as a regular starter.

6. Andre Onana - £47.2 Million from Inter Milan

Onana arrived at United amid much fanfare, touted as a goalkeeper who could play out from the back and enhance the team’s build-up play. While he has displayed moments of brilliance, his inconsistency and errors have raised questions about his reliability. The club’s decision to stick with him will likely depend on his ability to minimize mistakes in the upcoming season. Should he continue to falter, Onana may find himself on the transfer list as the club seeks to strengthen its goalkeeping options.

7. Joshua Zirkzee - £36 Million

Joshua Zirkzee was signed to add depth to the attacking options at United. The young forward has shown potential in his appearances, but he has struggled to secure a regular starting spot. While he possesses skill and a good eye for goal, consistency has eluded him. Zirkzee's future will depend on his ability to adapt and perform when given opportunities. He may face competition from other strikers, which could affect his place in the squad moving forward.

8. Manuel Ugarte - £50.8 Million

Manuel Ugarte's arrival was aimed at strengthening United's midfield. The Uruguayan has demonstrated strong tackling and a good work rate, making him a valuable addition to the squad. However, like many of his peers, Ugarte has struggled to maintain consistent form. If he can find his footing, he has the potential to become an essential part of Ten Hag's system. Nevertheless, if he fails to deliver, Ugarte could find himself on the chopping block as the club looks to optimize its midfield options.

9. Matthijs de Ligt - £43 Million f

Matthijs de Ligt was signed to enhance United's defensive solidity. The Dutch international possesses leadership qualities and a strong defensive skill set. However, since his arrival, he has faced challenges adapting to the Premier League's physicality and pace. While his talent is unquestionable, De Ligt’s ability to perform consistently will determine whether he remains a key figure in United’s backline or if he becomes another expensive misstep.

Overall, Ten Hag's signings present a mixed bag of potential successes and significant disappointments. Lisandro Martínez stands out as the most effective acquisition, while Antony's status as the most expensive signing raises concerns about his long-term fit. With several players, including Mount, Onana, and Zirkzee, facing uncertain futures, Manchester United finds itself at a crossroads. As the club prepares for another season, it must evaluate its investment strategy and focus on maximizing the potential of its squad, ensuring that the lessons learned during Ten Hag's tenure guide future decisions.